
Would Softcore suit the people on your Rust server?
Try Softcore if your group wants to spend less of its play session replacing lost gear. Start by testing what a friend brings back after a death during a normal gathering trip.
Start the test on a separate world
Use a test server with +server.gamemode softcore in its startup settings. Use a second test world with the mode unset for standard survival. Keep the mode change away from a world people already play on because changing modes can clear a player’s state.
Facepunch’s Soft Refresh describes automatic recovery of part of your inventory when you die outside a building privilege area. Test in open ground away from cupboards. Bring a few cheap items you can identify, record what you carried and compare what remains after respawning.
Compare what it takes to get back to playing
Have the same person do the route in both modes and say what they had to replace to continue. If the group also cares about gathering speed or what happens to a base while everyone is logged out, make those separate tests before choosing.
Facepunch has revised Softcore over time. Base your description on the checks you make on the build you intend to run.